The best customizable eyeshadow palettes let you arrange shades around your routine, but the right pick depends on whether you need a ready-made color set or an empty case for pans you already own. My best overall pick is the Z Palette Medium Deep Magnetic Makeup Palette for a balance of usable capacity and a more substantial organizer format. The Z Palette Large with Clear Window suits larger collections, while the Allwon Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette is a practical choice for arranging individual pans with included metal stickers. The main tradeoff is between compact storage and room to grow, with compatibility and portability also shaping the choice. Read on for the full breakdown of all seven options and the buyer factors that matter before choosing.
Get beauty and skincare favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Z Palette Medium Deep is the most balanced organizer pick: it offers a more focused alternative to the Large model when you want to arrange a collection without committing to the biggest case.
- The Large Z Palette favors visibility and capacity: its clear window makes shade identification easier, but a larger format may be less convenient for frequent travel.
- Included metal stickers affect setup: the Allwon palette is suited to pans that are not magnetic, while sticker-based conversion adds a step before rearranging shades.
- The three-compartment case and two-piece organizer set prioritize separation: they may suit users sorting shades or products by purpose better than a single open-pan layout.
- The Physicians Formula kit is the ready-made option: unlike empty organizers, it supplies a coordinated eye-color kit, so it offers less freedom to curate individual pans.
| Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette with Mirror, 3 Compartments |  | Best Compact Pick | Material: ABS, magnet, and iron | Color: Black and silver | Palette dimensions: 11 × 7 × 1.3 cm | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Fillwie Pink Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette with Detachable Mirror, Small |  | Best for Flexible Pan Layouts | Brand: Fillwie | Color: Pink | Capacity: Up to 9 standard 1-inch pans or approximately 16 smaller 0.8-inch pans | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Kit |  | Best Ready-to-Use Eye Kit | Eyeshadows: 9 | Eyeliners: 2 | Mascaras: 2 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Allwon Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette with 15 Metal Stickers |  | Best for Building a Larger Custom Palette | Palette size: 15 × 10 cm (5.9 × 3.9 in) | Capacity: Up to 15 pans | Compatible pan diameter: 1 in | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 2-Piece Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette Organizer Set |  | Best Two-Palette Set | Set size: 2 palettes | Dimensions: 4.28 × 2.79 × 0.55 in each | Pan slot dimensions: 1.11 × 1.22 in | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Z Palette Medium Deep Magnetic Makeup Palette |  | Best for Thicker and Dome-Shaped Pans | Capacity: Up to 15 standard 26 mm eyeshadows | Design: Medium deep | Included stickers: 16 metal stickers: 8 round and 8 square | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Z Palette Large Magnetic Makeup Palette with Clear Window |  | Best for Larger Custom Collections | Type: Empty magnetic makeup palette | Outside dimensions: 8.06 × 4.94 × 0.56 inches | Inside dimensions: 7.44 × 4.13 × 0.25 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette with Mirror, 3 Compartments
For a small, self-edited color selection, this three-pan magnetic palette keeps compatible makeup together without the footprint of a full-size organizer. Its built-in mirror also makes it more practical for touch-ups than the Allwon Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette, which is designed around larger capacity. The included iron pans give you three compartments to fill, so it can work for a mini eyeshadow trio or a mix of small makeup essentials. The tradeoff is its strict limit: only three pans are included, and the compact 11 × 7 cm body leaves little room to expand. I’d choose it for portability and a tightly curated edit, not for building a broad shade collection.
Pros:- Compact dimensions make it easy to carry
- Magnetic base helps hold compatible pans in place
- Includes three iron pans for immediate custom organization
- Built-in mirror supports on-the-go application
Cons:- Only three pans are included, limiting the size of a custom palette
- Small format offers less room than the 15-pan Allwon palette
- Product details do not state compatibility with specific pan sizes
Best for: Travelers or minimal-makeup users who want a mirror-equipped case for up to three selected pans.
Not ideal for: Buyers building a large eyeshadow collection or wanting room to add many shades; three included pans and the compact body limit capacity.
- Material:ABS, magnet, and iron
- Color:Black and silver
- Palette dimensions:11 × 7 × 1.3 cm
- Pan dimensions:5.5 × 3 cm each
- Included pans:3 iron pans
- Included items:1 magnetic palette and 3 iron pans
- Features:Mirror and magnetic base
Our verdict“Choose this if portability and a built-in mirror matter more than fitting a wide range of shades.”
Fillwie Pink Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette with Detachable Mirror, Small
The Fillwie stands out for buyers who want to arrange different pan sizes rather than commit to a fixed insert. It holds up to nine standard 1-inch pans or roughly 16 smaller pans, and its detachable mirror can be repositioned inside, outside, or on a magnetic surface. Unlike the Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette with Mirror, 3 Compartments, it does not include pans; instead, 20 adhesive metal stickers and a spatula help adapt nonmetal pans and handle refills. That flexibility comes with a setup step, and actual capacity depends on pan fit and size. Its paperboard construction is lightweight for travel, but buyers seeking a rigid plastic case may prefer the Allwon palette.
Pros:- Fits different pan sizes, with capacity listed for standard and smaller pans
- Detachable mirror can be placed in multiple positions
- Includes 20 adhesive metal stickers and a double-ended spatula
- Lightweight, compact format suits travel
Cons:- Makeup pans are not included
- Capacity depends on the size and fit of the selected pans
- Reinforced paperboard may not suit buyers who want a hard plastic case
Best for: Makeup users with a mix of compatible refill pans who want a light, configurable case and a mirror they can reposition.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a ready-filled palette or prefer a rigid plastic organizer; pans are not included, and capacity varies with pan dimensions.
- Brand:Fillwie
- Color:Pink
- Capacity:Up to 9 standard 1-inch pans or approximately 16 smaller 0.8-inch pans
- Dimensions:4.1 × 4.1 × 0.5 in
- Weight:0.14 kg
- Material:Reinforced water-resistant paperboard
- Included accessories:Detachable magnetic mirror, 20 adhesive metal stickers, and double-ended metal spatula
- Closure and inner depth:Magnetic closure; approximately 5 mm inner depth
Our verdict“Pick the Fillwie if you value adjustable layout and a repositionable mirror and are comfortable sourcing your own pans.”
Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Kit
Unlike the empty organizers in this roundup, the Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips kit arrives as a complete eye-makeup set: nine eyeshadows, two eyeliners, and two mascaras. Its shadows can be applied wet for stronger color or dry for a softer finish, giving one preset selection more range than a simple collection of refill pans. The tradeoff is that this is not a magnetic palette you can rearrange or refill, so it offers less customization than the Fillwie Pink Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette. The description also does not identify the individual shade colors, which makes it harder to judge whether the selection suits your preferred looks. Its sensitive-eye and contact-lens positioning may appeal to some buyers, but it is best for convenience rather than custom shade curation.
Pros:- Combines nine eyeshadows with two eyeliners and two mascaras
- Shadows can be applied wet or dry for different finishes
- Eyeliners are described as water-resistant and smudge-resistant
- Formulated for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Cons:- Does not offer the refillable, rearrangeable format of the empty magnetic palettes
- Individual eyeshadow colors are not specified in the product details
- Preset contents may not match a buyer’s preferred shade range
Best for: Shoppers who want a ready-made eye kit with shadows, liners, and mascaras rather than an empty palette to fill themselves.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want to choose, rearrange, or replace individual shades; this kit is a preset collection, and individual shade colors are not specified.
- Eyeshadows:9
- Eyeliners:2
- Mascaras:2
- Eyeshadow application:Wet for intense color or dry for a softer finish
- Eyeliner wear:Designed for up to 24 hours
- Eyeliner formula:Water-resistant and smudge-resistant
- Suitable for:Sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
- Formulated without:Fragrance, parabens, and gluten
Our verdict“Choose this kit for a ready-to-use assortment of eye products, not for building a personalized refill palette.”
Allwon Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette with 15 Metal Stickers
The Allwon is the capacity pick for anyone assembling a substantial custom color selection: it holds up to 15 one-inch pans, far more than the three-pan Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette with Mirror. Its 15 adhesive metal stickers let you use pans that are not already magnetic, so you are not limited to metal-backed refills. That larger layout is useful for grouping shades by finish or look, but it does not include makeup pans, and every pan must fit the stated size and height limits. At a maximum pan height of 3.5 mm, deeper products may not sit properly. Compared with the two-piece organizer set, the Allwon offers one larger palette rather than two separate compact cases.
Pros:- Holds up to 15 pans for a larger customized selection
- Includes 15 adhesive metal stickers for nonmetal pans
- Reusable plastic construction can be cleaned and refilled
- Protective film on the mirror can be removed before use
Cons:- Makeup pans are not included
- Pan fit is limited to 1-inch diameter and 3.5 mm maximum height
- Larger single-case format is less compact than the Fillwie palette
Best for: DIY palette builders who already own or plan to source up to 15 shallow, one-inch pans and want one organized case.
Not ideal for: Buyers with deeper pans, larger pans, or no refills on hand; makeup is not included and the 3.5 mm height limit restricts compatibility.
- Palette size:15 × 10 cm (5.9 × 3.9 in)
- Capacity:Up to 15 pans
- Compatible pan diameter:1 in
- Maximum pan height:3.5 mm
- Material:Plastic
- Included stickers:15 adhesive metal stickers
- Mirror:Protective film to remove before use
- Makeup pans included:No
Our verdict“Choose the Allwon if you want one roomy palette and your pans fit its shallow, one-inch format.”
2-Piece Empty Magnetic Makeup Palette Organizer Set
This set offers a different kind of customization: rather than making one large palette, you get two separate compact cases for splitting shades by color family, formula, or daily use. The transparent lids let you identify the contents without opening each case, while built-in mirrors add convenience for touch-ups. Compared with the Allwon, the pair is easier to divide and carry, but it cannot hold as many pans in one place. The magnetic base is intended for metal-pan cosmetics; plastic or aluminum pans may need stickers, which are not included. That missing accessory matters if your collection is mostly nonmagnetic. I’d choose this set for organized separation, not for the broadest pan capacity or a fully adaptable starter kit.
Pros:- Two cases let you separate shades or makeup categories
- Transparent lids make contents visible at a glance
- Built-in mirrors support touch-ups away from home
- Compact dimensions make each case easy to carry
Cons:- Magnetic base works with metal pans; other pan materials may need stickers
- Metal stickers for incompatible pans are not included
- Two compact cases provide less single-palette capacity than the Allwon
Best for: Makeup users who want two small cases to separate everyday shades from a secondary selection or organize different cosmetic types.
Not ideal for: Buyers with mostly nonmetal pans who want everything included to secure them, or anyone seeking one high-capacity palette; stickers are not supplied.
- Set size:2 palettes
- Dimensions:4.28 × 2.79 × 0.55 in each
- Pan slot dimensions:1.11 × 1.22 in
- Features:Magnetic base, transparent lid, and built-in mirror
- Compatible products:Metal-pan cosmetics
- Intended use:Eyeshadow, blush, lipstick, and powder storage
- Nonmetal pan support:Plastic or aluminum pans may need metal stickers; stickers are not included
Our verdict“Pick this set if you want two portable, easy-to-identify organizers and already use metal-backed pans.”
Z Palette Medium Deep Magnetic Makeup Palette
The Medium Deep Z Palette is the better fit when your existing collection includes dome-shaped shadows or pans that sit higher than standard pressed powders. Its extra depth gives those pans more room than the Large Z Palette, whose listed interior depth is just 0.25 inches. Capacity is up to 15 standard 26 mm eyeshadows, so this pick favors accommodating pan shape over maximizing storage. It also comes with 16 metal stickers for pans that are not magnetic, though attaching those takes an extra step. The clear window folds beneath the palette to save space when open. I’d choose it for a carefully edited mix of unusual pans, but skip it if you want a ready-filled kit: makeup is not included.
Pros:- Extra depth accommodates dome-shaped and thicker pans
- Holds up to 15 standard 26 mm eyeshadows
- Includes 16 metal stickers for non-metal pans
- Clear window folds underneath to save space
Cons:- Empty palette; eyeshadows and other makeup are not included
- Non-metal pans require attaching the included stickers
- Capacity may feel limited for buyers organizing a larger collection
Best for: Makeup collectors with dome-shaped or thicker pans who want to build a custom selection from products they already own.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a pre-filled eyeshadow set, or anyone who wants to load many standard pans rather than prioritize extra pan clearance.
- Capacity:Up to 15 standard 26 mm eyeshadows
- Design:Medium deep
- Included stickers:16 metal stickers: 8 round and 8 square
- Window:Clear window folds beneath the palette
- Palette contents:Empty palette; makeup not included
- Attachment:Magnetic pans attach directly; non-metal pans need included stickers
Our verdict“Choose this Z Palette if pan height is a bigger concern than maximizing capacity; otherwise, compare its 15-pan limit with the larger Z Palette.”
Z Palette Large Magnetic Makeup Palette with Clear Window
For buyers who want more room to arrange a mixed collection, the Large Z Palette is the more storage-oriented choice in this pair. Its interior measures 7.44 × 4.13 inches, and the clear window makes it easier to identify what is inside without opening it. A magnetic closure keeps the palette shut, while 20 round stickers let non-magnetic pans join the layout. Compared with the Medium Deep Z Palette, this model offers a larger stated interior but has a 0.25-inch interior depth, making it less suited to unusually thick or domed pans. The Medium Deep option is the safer pick when pan height matters. This palette is empty, too, so it helps reorganize makeup rather than supplying shades.
Pros:- Larger interior than the Medium Deep Z Palette
- Clear window shows contents without opening the palette
- Magnetic closure keeps the palette shut
- Includes 20 round magnetic stickers for non-magnetic pans
Cons:- Interior depth is limited to 0.25 inches
- Makeup products are not included
- Non-magnetic pans need stickers attached before they can be arranged
Best for: Makeup users consolidating a broader selection of standard-height eyeshadow and powder pans who value visible contents and a magnetic closure.
Not ideal for: Collectors with dome-shaped or thick pans who need extra clearance, or buyers expecting a palette that comes with makeup.
- Type:Empty magnetic makeup palette
- Outside dimensions:8.06 × 4.94 × 0.56 inches
- Inside dimensions:7.44 × 4.13 × 0.25 inches
- Closure:Magnetic
- Window:Clear
- Included stickers:20 round magnetic stickers
- Palette contents:Empty palette; makeup not included
Our verdict“Pick the Large Z Palette for a roomier layout of standard-height pans, but choose the Medium Deep model if your collection includes thicker or domed products.”
How We Picked
I compared these seven options by how well they serve two different meanings of customizable: rearranging individual pans and choosing a coordinated, ready-made assortment. For empty palettes, I focused on magnetic compatibility, capacity, layout, visibility, portability, and how much setup may be needed to fit nonmagnetic pans. I also considered practical details such as compartments, a mirror, a detachable mirror, and included metal stickers, since these features change how a palette works day to day.
The ranking favors flexible organizers that offer a clear use case without adding unnecessary setup or bulk. The Z Palette Medium Deep leads as a balanced choice; the Large model ranks higher for users whose priority is capacity and visibility, not compactness. Allwon earns distinction for its included stickers, while the multi-compartment and two-piece options serve sorting needs. The Fillwie case stands out for its small format and detachable mirror, and the Physicians Formula kit is included as the ready-to-use alternative rather than a fully customizable empty palette.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Customizable Eyeshadow Palettes
Before choosing a case, I would decide what “customizable” means for your makeup routine. Some buyers want to move existing single shadows between layouts; others want a coordinated kit they can use straight away. These differences affect compatibility, capacity, and what counts as good value for your collection.
Check Pan Compatibility Before Buying
A magnetic palette only holds pans securely when the pan itself is magnetic or when a compatible metal sticker is added. Check whether your shadows are loose singles, removable pans from another palette, or still fixed inside their original packaging. A sticker can help adapt a nonmagnetic pan, but it adds a preparation step and may not suit pans you want to return to their original case. Avoid assuming every pressed shadow can be lifted cleanly from its packaging. If you are unsure, test one inexpensive or replaceable pan before reorganizing a full collection. This simple check can matter more than the palette’s appearance or listed capacity.
Choose Capacity for Your Actual Routine
Estimate how many pans you reach for regularly, then leave room for a few additions rather than buying to an imagined future collection. A large case can keep more shades together, but unused space adds bulk and can make a kit less convenient to carry. A compact format works well for a small edit, though it may fill quickly if you depot many shades. Think about whether you need one daily palette or a storage home for your whole single-shadow collection. Grouping by use—such as neutrals, color, or travel favorites—can make a smaller organizer more functional. Buying the largest size by default is a common way to end up with a case that stays at home.
Decide Whether You Need Separation or One Open Layout
Compartments and multiple cases help separate shades by finish, color family, or occasion, while one open magnetic surface makes it easier to rearrange a set as a single palette. Separation is useful if you often switch between workday neutrals and brighter looks, or if you want a smaller selection ready to pack. The tradeoff is that dividing pans can make a collection less convenient to view all at once. A single layout is simpler to scan but may not keep categories distinct. Before choosing, sketch how you would group your current pans and how often those groups change. Pick the layout that reduces the searching and rearranging you actually do.
Weigh Portability Against Mirror and Visibility Features
A mirror can make a palette more useful away from your usual makeup space, but it does not automatically make a case travel-ready. Size, closure, pan security, and how easily the case fits into your bag also matter. A clear window can help identify shades without opening the case, especially when you store several palettes together. On the other hand, a window is less useful if you keep the palette in a drawer or prefer to see the pans directly. Detachable mirrors offer a different kind of flexibility, but they add a component you may need to keep track of. Match these features to where you apply and store makeup rather than treating them as universal upgrades.
Factor in Setup, Maintenance, and Future Changes
Custom palettes can require more upkeep than a factory-assembled kit: loose powder, adhesive residue, and changing pan arrangements all take time to manage. If you plan to move shades often, favor a layout that makes pans accessible and easy to reposition. Stickers can broaden compatibility, but frequent changes may mean extra handling compared with magnetic pans that fit directly. Keep the case clean and avoid forcing pans that sit unevenly, since a poor fit can make storage frustrating. Also consider whether your collection changes with seasons or new purchases. A ready-made kit asks less of you upfront, while an empty palette pays off most when you expect to curate and update your own selection.
Compare Customization With a Ready-Made Kit
An empty magnetic case gives you control over shades and arrangement, but it assumes you already have pans to fill it or want to source them separately. A coordinated kit is easier to use immediately, though its shade selection and layout are predetermined. Think about whether you value curation enough to handle compatibility and setup, or whether you would rather have a complete set in one purchase. Avoid choosing an empty palette solely because it sounds more flexible if you do not own loose pans. Conversely, a ready-made assortment may duplicate colors you already have. The best fit depends on whether convenience or control solves the bigger problem for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I put any eyeshadow pan in a magnetic palette?
No. The pan needs to be magnetic or paired with a compatible metal sticker, and its size must fit the available space. Some shadows remain attached to their original packaging and may not be easy to remove without damage. Check how your pans are constructed before buying an empty case. If you plan to depot them, try one pan first rather than risking a whole set. Compatibility is the first question to settle, not an assumption to make after purchase.
Is a clear-window palette better than one with a mirror?
They solve different problems. A clear window helps you identify shades while the case is closed, which is useful when palettes are stored together or stacked. A mirror is more helpful if you apply makeup away from a fixed vanity mirror. Neither feature guarantees better portability, since overall size and how securely pans sit still matter. Choose based on whether you spend more time finding shades or applying them away from home.
Should I buy a large palette if I expect my collection to grow?
Only if you have a clear reason to keep a larger set together. Extra capacity can reduce the need to reorganize, but it also creates more bulk and may be inconvenient to carry. Estimate the number of pans you own now and how quickly you add new ones, then leave a modest amount of room. If your collection changes by color family or occasion, multiple smaller groupings may be easier to use than one large case. Capacity is most useful when the layout stays practical for your routine.
Are included metal stickers worth choosing over a basic empty case?
They can be useful if some of your loose pans are not magnetic, since stickers may let those pans attach to a magnetic base. They do not remove the need to check pan size, and applying them adds preparation work. If most of your pans already attach magnetically, included stickers may not change your decision much. Consider how often you expect to move or replace pans, since stickers can make that process less direct. Their value depends on the makeup you already own, not just the number included.
Is a ready-made eyeshadow kit a good choice if I want customization?
It can be a good fit if you want a coordinated set that is ready to use, but it offers less control over individual shades than an empty magnetic palette. A kit such as the Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Kit is a different kind of choice from the organizer cases in this roundup. It may suit someone who values a prepared assortment more than rearranging personal pans. Before choosing it, check whether its color selection fits the looks you wear and whether you already own similar shades. If building a personal mix is the main goal, an empty palette is the closer match.
Conclusion
For most buyers who want to arrange their own pans, I recommend the Z Palette Medium Deep as the best overall balance of capacity and focused storage. The Allwon magnetic palette is my best value-style pick for shoppers who need included metal stickers to adapt nonmagnetic pans, while the Z Palette Large with Clear Window is the best premium-style option for a larger collection that benefits from quick shade visibility. Beginners who would rather skip depotting and setup should look at the Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips kit as a ready-made starting point, though it is less customizable. For compact use, the Fillwie small palette is the more targeted choice; for sorting by category, compare the three-compartment palette and two-piece organizer set. Choose based on your pan compatibility and daily routine first, then let capacity and extras settle the final decision.
Halloween Picks
Panefright Halloween Window Projector – Scary Projector for Spooky Decor
JOYIN 5-Foot Halloween Animatronic Drinking Skeleton
Kalolary 12ft Halloween Witch Haunted House Inflatable Archway
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
